DAW Reviews: An Introduction to Digital Audio Workstations
DAW got you down? We broke down the functions and capabilities of some of the most popular digital audio workstations—so you don’t have to.
This interview originally appeared in She Shreds Magazine Issue #16, released December 2018.
Digital Audio Workstations (DAW) are computer programs specifically designed for music production. Nearly all of them offer similar capabilities, but each one has a unique workflow that could significantly impact the user’s experience and ability to quickly translate ideas. For those interested in recording, mixing, mastering, or composing with a DAW, it’s a good idea to try the free demo versions before committing. Though each DAW has its own learning curve, different artists may find different stations more inspiring to work with.
All of these will be much easier to use with a recording interface and dedicated MIDI controllers, but that’s for another article. First, let’s find which DAW feels right.
The Industry Standard
Price: Free-$2,499
Subscription option: as low as $24.92 a month
Supported platforms: Mac, PC
Pro Tools is truly the music industry standard, but it’s important to note that other industries using this DAW include gaming, television, and film. If you ever find yourself in a collaborative professional environment, you’re very likely to run into companies, studios, and producers that rely on this software.
A good place to start is Pro Tools First, the free version of the software that allows users to work with up to 16 mono or stereo tracks of audio, four of which may be recorded simultaneously. Pro Tools First also comes bundled with plenty of samples, loops, effects, and the virtual instrument Xpand!2. When used in conjunction with the built-in MIDI editor, Xpand!2 can be used to add synth and drum sounds to a track. This is an adequate set of tools for songwriters or small bands to cut a demo, for future producers to learn how to create beats or EDM, as well as anyone who wants to learn how to mix music.
One major limitation to Pro Tools First is its ability to only save three projects at a time, which basically means that if you want to make more songs, then you’ll have to delete your session file to make room.
Pro Tools Ultimate, the flagship version of the software, will allow you to work with video and create surround-sound mixes with up to 768 tracks on an HD system—up to 192 of which may be simultaneously recorded. Bundled with Pro Tools Ultimate is a massive library of sounds, virtual instruments, and effects that sound professional enough for Top 40 songs. There is much more to say about the capabilities of Pro Tools Ultimate, but the fact that AVID has had a hand in numerous top-grossing songs and films since 1999 should speak volumes.
The Electronic Musician/Hip-Hop Producer’s Dream
Price: $99-$749 (free 30 day trial)
Subscription option: None
Supported platforms: Mac, PC
Ableton Live is still relatively young. Having debuted in 2001, its developers created something truly unique for the music industry: Ableton Live is a DAW that is also designed to be integrated on stages and used live, hence its namesake. The program’s ability to loop multiple clips at the same time lets the user quickly sketch and try out ideas on the fly. A clip can be as short or long as you wish (hard drive space pending) and can be made up of either audio or MIDI files.
The entire program was designed to not be taxing on a computer in order to have greater stability in a live environment. It also supports virtually every MIDI controller on the market, ranging from tons of drum pads, controllers, and keyboards, to their very own Push 2, which enables the user to control nearly every feature in Ableton Live without having to rely on the computer’s screen, keyboard, or mouse.
Ableton Live is also capable of recording and mixing any band within any genre on a professional level due to its strong editing and routing capabilities and high-quality effects. The entire Ableton Live Suite—their flagship product that literally comes with over 50 gigs (yes, gigs) of ready to use samples, instruments, and loops—is available without limitations in a free 30-day trial.
The New All Arounder
Price: Free-$399.95
Subscription option: None
Supported platforms: Mac, PC
At the time of PreSonus Studio One’s debut in 2009, the pro audio world was not short on DAW options, but Studio One changed everything with three words: drag and drop. It’s really easy to overlook how much of an impact this had on the industry. With Studio One, it became possible to drag a copy of an effects chain from one track to another, complete with identical settings and with just a click of a mouse and flick of a wrist. PreSonus implemented this technology into everything within the software, and the result for many was a much quicker way of getting things done. On top of this, Studio One also integrated a true mastering suite that was not only capable of putting the finishing touches on tracks, but could also deliver all of the formats that a record plant or music distributor might need, such RedBook standard CDs and DDP files.
All of this, along with a seriously powerful MIDI editor with great sounding virtual instruments and samplers, makes Studio One worth checking out for any musician or producer looking for a DAW that is very capable of meeting the needs of numerous different types of projects.
The One for Folks Who Miss the Analog Days
Price:$79-$299
Subscription option: None
Supported platforms: Mac, PC, Linux
Harrison Designs is the only company that has designed both legendary analog consoles and modern DAW software. During the ‘70s and ‘80s, Harrison Designs cemented their place in music history as folks like Janet and Michael Jackson, ABBA, and Queen started using their consoles to make records. This put Harrison at a great advantage when they ultimately ventured into creating DAW software, as the company really understands how a traditional analog console should look, feel, and sound.
Tracking and mixing music are definitely Harrison Mixbus’s strong suit, and it is evident from the moment you open your first project. At the heart of the software is the mixer page, which is laid out just like an old analog recording console—this will look familiar to anyone who has worked with a traditional console before. Every channel has its own EQ, compressor, and input trim controls complete with analog-style metering and routing. The software even emulates the sound of an analog console; I find it quite nice that it even recreates the sound of tape whirring when using the transport controls. All of this means I rarely have to dive through any menus, since most of what I use is already quite visible.
Harrison’s DAW can be a little heavy on the CPU, but I also don’t have to use nearly as many plug-ins in order to add a certain warmth to a mix that I would in every other DAW. Though it has basic editing functions and MIDI as well, this software really shines when used with more traditional projects like recording and mixing a band or song, more so than when creating electronic music that would require a significant amount of editing or virtual instruments.
Free demo versions are available for both Harrison Mixbus and Mixbus 32c, which emulates a larger console with a bigger EQ section and even more routing along with effects and virtual instruments. While the demo versions leave everything unlocked, there are intermittent noises to prevent you from really making any songs, so it truly exists just for the sake of getting a feel for the software.
Comments
Don’t forget Cakewalk by Bandlab. Just as good as any of the DAWs mentioned and it’s free, which makes it an excellent choice for a beginner.
Comment by Jeremy Jensen on November 2, 2019 at 9:29 pmFor the folks who want to give something a test spin: Audacity. It is amazing what this will do for free. I used it for years before buying Studio One 4 Professional.
Comment by Deb Murphy on June 23, 2020 at 1:34 pmThey’re all too complicated. I miss the days of a simple tape recorder. You could go to a Walgreens, buy some batteries, a tape and a machine. Get high in the park, and see what comes out. DAW has killed that spontaneity.
Now I use my phone for the first round of recording and save up money to record in a studio for the rest of the project.
Comment by Andrea on June 24, 2020 at 1:42 pmDeveloping your business effectively is crucial to your success, but it can be challenging to know where to start. Fortunately, there are many resources available to help you develop a solid marketing strategy, but you can use something like magento 2 add free product to cart. From online courses to marketing consultants, there’s no shortage of options to choose from.
Comment by Dann on May 7, 2023 at 1:33 pmI think the main purpose is that it helps simplify our lives. I know you agree with me. The development of applications or other software is, by the way, a very long and complex process that needs to be constantly monitored. When I had to create my own website, I decided to know more about Incognito mode: how to use it in browsers and it has made it easier to manage the website’s development process and project changes.
Comment by ArnoldTaylor on May 23, 2023 at 9:36 amI used to work alone and develop various mobile applications. But recently I received a very complex and large order. That is why I decided to look find something like video API, so I started to read more about that and it turned out helpful. If you are also involved in development, I suggest you do the same.
Comment by Daniel on May 30, 2023 at 9:02 amI’m focused on improving my development skills, and I think Microsoft Office can be a great aid. If you know where to find it or can suggest similar service, your input would be invaluable. Thank you for your assistance.
Comment by Carl on October 16, 2023 at 5:03 amTo be honest, there are so many programs like that, but not all of them work well. You can check Microsoft office for Mac and find services you need. However, I believe that it is better not to save money. Besides, I’ve heard lots of people use that.
Comment by Erwin on October 16, 2023 at 5:05 amWhen it comes to custom software and mobile app development for music production, precision and creativity are paramount. Crafting computer programs tailored to the needs of musicians and producers is a unique challenge, and it’s great to see firms like https://gowombat.team/ that specialize in delivering solutions for this niche.
Comment by Joan on October 22, 2023 at 5:23 pmIn the realm of music production, having software that meets the demands of artists and producers can be a game-changer. It’s not just about functionality but also the user experience, which directly impacts creativity and efficiency
My friends are probably surprised at how useless I use my computer, because in my spare time I just gamble. To be honest, I have no desire to download any programs or even video games. It’s much easier to go to platform https://tower.bet/, choose a cool game and have a great time. In addition, it can generate income.
Comment by Gifford on January 4, 2024 at 2:06 amI am sure that no matter what the job is, it is tiring in any case. Many people at the end of the working day want to do something simple, perhaps relaxing, distracting. For me, such a solution is definitely gambling, and especially Bitcoin dice, which I found here https://duckdice.io/. This platform seems reliable, so if you are looking, I advise you to start with this resource.
Comment by Gifford on February 12, 2024 at 6:47 am